Hello dear
Welcome to Casey's Monmouth
At Casey's Monmouth, located in the heart of Monmouth, IL, the story is one of community, quality, and passion for great food. This beloved pizza spot not only serves delicious, freshly made pizzas but also delights with an array of bakery treats, from doughnuts to pastries. Patrons rave about the bold flavors of Casey’s coffee selections and the crispy wings. Under the stewardship of talented kitchen manager Jessie Fye, every dish reflects dedication to quality. With takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating, Casey's Monmouth is a gathering place where every meal is an experience, inviting guests to savor the essence of homemade goodness.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Marinara Sauce
Create Your Own Pizza
Nestle Tollhouse Vanilla Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich
Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 16oz
About
Casey's Monmouth
Welcome to Casey's Monmouth, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Monmouth, Illinois. Located at 1137 N Main St, Casey's promises a delightful culinary experience centered around pizza, sandwiches, and an array of freshly baked goodies. This beloved establishment stands out not just for its extensive menu, but for the warmth and hospitality it extends to every guest.
When you enter Casey's, you'll immediately feel the inviting atmosphere. The store shines bright and is neatly organized, making it a welcoming stop for weary travelers and local food enthusiasts alike. Their commitment to quality and freshness is evident in every dish served. The kitchen, helmed by the talented Jessie Fye, creates food that has garnered praise for its outstanding quality. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked dishes and the delicious selection available, showcasing a sincere commitment to culinary excellence.
- Pizza: The star attraction at Casey's, offering a variety of flavors that cater to all palates.
- Hot Sandwiches: Don't miss the Breaded Pork Tenderloin Sandwich, perfectly crispy and customizable to your taste.
- Bakery Delights: From the classic Glazed Donut to the indulgent Maple Pecan Danish, each item promises a sweet escape.
- Ice Cream: Indulge in the latest offerings from the Happyness by the Pint range, featuring flavors like Peanut Butter Me Up, a decadent blend you're sure to love.
The feedback from loyal patrons speaks volumes. James Pittman took a moment to commend the staff's kindness, while Nick Vasquez highlighted the meticulous care that Jessie's baking has brought to the menu. It's this kind of personal touch that transforms a simple meal into a memorable dining experience. As Kristopher King noted, grabbing a cold beer alongside delicious doughnuts makes for a perfect pairing.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning a family meal, Casey's Monmouth welcomes you with open arms. With great food, friendly service, and a clean environment, Casey's isn't just a place to eat; it's a community hub that turns every visit into an occasion. Make sure to stop in, say hi to Jessie, and experience the culinary charm of Casey's for yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Michelle, thank you so much. I purchased 2 gal of antifreeze that was not enough for my truck. You took the 2 empty jugs and filled them with water from your faucet in the kitchen without a 2nd thought.. That was very kind of you. ”
“ Good drink specials VERY busy this visit friendly service. Clean store ”
“ Walk in and the place is bright, clean and organized! So much of everything good! I can imagine a tired, hungry, drowsy traveler walking into this store and being amazed how everything is right at his fingertips! The coffee has never been bad here as far as I know...and trust me I would NEVER lie about coffee!lol The food is great! Jessie Fye is the Kitchen Manager there and she really makes their food outstanding! The quality of the food is perfect and should be used as an example to all other Caseys! Never have I had a bad kitchen item since they hired Jessie, years ago. Shes an extraordinary baker, and the quality of her work really shows in the food at Caseys! Theyre lucky to have her! The general merchandise is plentiful here at the Monmouth location. To be clear, we have THREE Caseys in Monmouth, but the North is my favorite because of Jessie youd follow her too if you ever tasted her cakes! Gas prices are fair here. Clerks are above normal polite wise. If you come in say hi to Jessie super sweet lady with a quick smile. Her doughnuts are to die for!lol P.S. the store is 3544 since that seems to be a National Secret! Caseys fix that and put on your website! Dont make me call your store or find a receipt to tell me that! ”
“ Good selection, food made on site, filling, tasty, clean restrooms, some have showers. Great pizza. ”
“ Allways a joy picking up my nice ice cold beers from the walkin beer cooler. Good Service Great Donuts ”
“ I was heading to To Ottumwa, Iowa and on the way there stopped for bathroom and food. The wonderful cooking person added Mayo Onion Lettuce and Tomato to my burger and it was delicious. It was so good forgot tonget gas. Not sure of exact town but heading up 34 West you cant go wrong...BRAVO ”
“ Well though out variety of donuts and coffee. Any type of snack imaginable. Fresh cold meat wraps and sandwiches plus salads and some vegey choices for your traveling munchies etc. Hot pizza sold by slice or take out. Fountain pop. Beer and liquor. Gas station. ”
“ Just had to leave a quick positive review since people tend to leave reviews only to highlight the negative. The manager and girl with long blonde hair are hard working w good attitudes. The store is clean and they always have my favorite cookies in stock. Keep it up, I know it isnt easy!! ”